$2,895,000Asking Price
204 Cottingham Street, Toronto C02, ON M4V 1C5
Rathnelly, Toronto
Tucked into the Republic of Rathnelly, one of Toronto's most unique and tightly held neighbourhoods, this striking Gable-Front Victorian offers a rare combination of scale, character, and location. Set on a quiet, tree-lined street where neighbours know each other and homes rarely come to market, this is the kind of address buyers wait years for. Inside, soaring ceilings on every level create a sense of volume rarely found, with a main floor that blends elegance and function through a formal living room with wood burning fireplace, a dining room with gas fireplace, and a kitchen that anchors daily life and entertaining. The second floor offers two bedrooms plus a flexible den easily converted back to a fifth, along with laundry and a primary suite with California Closets built-ins. The third floor adds two more bedrooms, including one with an integrated study area, and a walkout terrace above the city. A largely unspoiled lower level with wine cellar and side walkout offers exceptional future potential. Detached garage via shared drive with potential for additional rear parking. Steps to Summerhill, Nordheimer Ravine, Pump Park, transit, and within the coveted Brown School catchment. A rare opportunity in a true neighbourhood setting.
Tucked into the Republic of Rathnelly, one of Toronto's most unique and tightly held neighbourhoods, this striking Gable-Front Victorian offers a rare combination of scale, character, and location. Set on a quiet, tree-lined street where neighbours know each other and homes rarely come to market, this is the kind of address buyers wait years for. Inside, soaring ceilings on every level create a sense of volume rarely found, with a main floor that blends elegance and function through a formal living room with wood burning fireplace, a dining room with gas fireplace, and a kitchen that anchors daily life and entertaining. The second floor offers two bedrooms plus a flexible den easily converted back to a fifth, along with laundry and a primary suite with California Closets built-ins. The third floor adds two more bedrooms, including one with an integrated study area, and a walkout terrace above the city. A largely unspoiled lower level with wine cellar and side walkout offers exceptional future potential. Detached garage via shared drive with potential for additional rear parking. Steps to Summerhill, Nordheimer Ravine, Pump Park, transit, and within the coveted Brown School catchment. A rare opportunity in a true neighbourhood setting.
See MoreKey Info
- 3-Storey Semi-Detached
- 0-Car Driveway
- 1-Car Detached Garage
- Avenue Road and Cottingham Street
- 2500-3000 Approximate Sq Feet
- Unfinished Basement
- 1 Kitchen
- Forced Air Gas Heating
- Central Air
Property
- Lot Size 25.75 x 140 Feet
- Brick Exterior
- Taxes were $15,492 in 2026
- Possession: 60/90/120
Details
- Fireplace
- No Family Room
- Sewers
- Municipal Water
- MLS #C12991686
- ROYAL LEPAGE/J & D DIVISION
Extras
Rooms
| Room | Floor | Dimensions | Details | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | 1 2-Piece Bathroom on Ground Floor | |||
| 1 4-Piece Bathroom | |||
| 1 3-Piece Bathroom | |||
| 1 4-Piece Bathroom | |||
How Far is Too Far?
See personalized commute details for each listing by adding your favourite places (like work or daycare) and mode of travel.
Sign up to see commute timesAlready signed up? Sign in
Who lives here?
Rathnelly, Toronto is a central Toronto neighbourhood notable for its university grads, executives and business, science, education, law & public sector and arts & culture professionals. Residents tend to be younger with a significant number of adults aged 25 to 49 and seniors aged 65 to 74.
Families
Kids Per Family
0.7
kids per family
in the neighbourhood.
Gta ({{ '1.29999995231628' | number: 1 }})
Singles
47%
of residents are
single and loving it.
47% singles
Toronto (50%)Gta ({{ '44.8800010681152' | number: 0 }}%)
Renters
41%
of residents
are renters.
41% renters
Toronto (47%)Gta ({{ '33.0200004577637' | number: 0 }}%)
Education
79%
of residents are
university grads.
79% university grads
Toronto (48%)Gta ({{ '43.6699981689453' | number: 0 }}%)
Income
Average Household Income
$234K
is the average household
income in the neighbourhood.
Gta ({{ '135056.828125' | minifiedCurrency }})
Professions
Professions
| Government | 19% |
| Sales | 15% |
| Business | 12% |
| Management | 11% |
| Sciences | 7% |
Immigrants
21%
of residents were
born outside of Canada.
21% immigrants
Toronto (48%)Gta ({{ '45.4300003051758' | number: 0 }}%)
Birthplace - All
2.5% from UK
All-time
Birthplace - Recent
0.9% from India
Recent
Foreign Languages
Foreign Languages
| French | 3% |
| Russian | 2% |
| Spanish | 2% |
| Italian | 1% |
| Cantonese | 1% |
Religions
Religions
| Christian | 47% |
| Jewish | 11% |
| Hindu | 3% |
| Buddhist | 1% |
Social Housing
Social Housing Buildings
0
Social housing buildings
in the neighbourhood.
Shelters
Shelters
0
Homeless shelters in
the neighbourhood.
